Are You Supportive of the New Archbishop?

Salvatore Cordileone, formerly the bishop of Oakland, was vocal in support of Prop. 8 four years ago. As of Thursday, he is the archbishop of San Francisco, a position that oversees parishes in Marin.

A question for Novato's Catholics: Does it bother you that the new archbishop of San Francisco, who oversees parishes in Marin County, supported the ban on same-sex marriage that was passed four years ago? Or are you glad he did?

Anyone from Novato's LGBT community have a viewpoint on that?

Salvatore Cordileone was installed in the role Thursday afternoon at St. Mary's Cathedral in San Francisco after being appointed by Pope Benedict XVI in July to replace George Niederauer, who is retiring. But the move came amid protests from lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender groups because of Cordileone's support of Proposition 8.

The New York Times published a story about how gay Catholics are worried about Cordileone's installment. About 25 protesters carried signs and marched outside St. Mary's while an equal number clapped and sang in his favor. The LGBT protesters waved rainbow flags and carried signs with messages such as, "We all deserve the freedom to marry." Other protesters' signs decried priest abuse of children.

"It's really a smorgasbord" of protests, said demonstrator Billy Bradford, 56, of Castro Valley. "... I'm here for gay people in general. Cordileone has said we're against the natural order of things. No, we're not. We're people. We're family. I should be able to get married so that my son can be protected by two parents."

"We do not support his anti-equality message or the work he does to deny legal rights to our families," Billy Bradford of Marriage Equality USA said in a statement. "The harm done to our community by Salvatore Cordileone cannot go unchallenged."

Those supporting the new archbishop carried a sign reading, "Neocatechumenal communities welcome the new shepherd." They clapped and sang, accompanied by several guitarists and drummers.

On the plaza in front of the church, which was closed to the public, a mariachi band played. The band was part of one of several ethnic festivities organized for the installation by the archdiocese to celebrate the diverse cultures it encompasses.

Meanwhile, a steady stream of nuns and priests entered St. Mary's Cathedral on the Gough Street side. Cordileone walked into the church at 2:06 p.m., wearing a gold-threaded robe and a white mitre.

On top of the same-sex issue, Cordileone was arrested on suspicion of drunken driving in San Diego in August, and issued a statement apologizing for his "error in judgment" and "the disgrace I have brought upon the Church and myself." He is due back in court in that case next week.

His installation also brought skeptical comments from some members of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors at their meeting earlier this week.

Supervisor Christina Olague, who identifies herself as bisexual, said she was disappointed that the church would appoint "a person who has shown a great deal of intolerance for our community." Supervisor David Campos, who is gay, also noted what he said were divisive statements by Cordileone, but said, "I hope we can find some common ground."

Cordileone has served as bishop of Oakland since 2009 after serving as an auxiliary bishop in San Diego and spending time in Rome, Costa Mesa and Calexico.

Besides the city, the Archdiocese of San Francisco also includes San Mateo and Marin counties. The archbishop oversees the dioceses of Oakland, San Jose, Santa Rosa, Stockton, Sacramento, Las Vegas, Reno, Salt Lake City and Honolulu.

Do you have a stance on this issue? Add a comment below.

— Bay City News Service

Stay Patched in! Follow Novato Patch on Twitter | Like Novato Patch on Facebook | Sign up for the daily e-mail with links to the latest news.

JAN October 05, 2012 at 02:05 PM
Our new Archbishop, Pastor Bonus, but one who excludes many in his flock. Good man? Check. Devoted to God? Check. Human, see DUI, falability? Check. The Catholic Church founded by Peter, at the behest of Christ, sadly excludes many who would come to find peace and solace. We can only wonder what Christ would have said about LGBT and others who don't exactly fit.
EWC October 05, 2012 at 02:49 PM
This is the Catholic Church's position and it's call religious freedom.
Eileen Plunkett October 05, 2012 at 04:51 PM
The Catholic church and religious freedom???? Don't make me laugh, there is no such thing as religious freedom in the CC. The rule is "their way or the highway". I am a practicing Catholic.
Ralph Canine October 05, 2012 at 04:53 PM
As the Archbishop, he's the teacher and leader for all the Catholics of the Archdiocese, which means his calling is to proclaim the Faith consistent with the Catechism of the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church teaches that marriage is a sacrament, a mighty action of the Holy Spirit, a gift from God to the human race, and marriage can only be between one man and one woman. People who commit homosexual acts are not excluded from the Catholic Church. They are called to repentance and union with God, just like all the rest of the human race. It's a mistake to view the new Archbishop in political terms -- "Where does he stand on gay rights?" Instead, a better place to start learning about the Catholic Church's teaching on marriage is Pope John Paul II's "Love and Responsibility". Also, do a Google search on "the theology of the body" and prepare to be fascinated and inspired.
Cathy Timmer October 05, 2012 at 05:55 PM
I agree with our new Archbishop and respect him for staying true to his values. We need more people like this.
Craig Belfor October 05, 2012 at 08:34 PM
I don't get it. How come a religion that promotes and supports gay sex be against gay marriage? Look at the rules for priesthood: You can't like women You have to wear a dress You have to hang out with little boys all the time Really- who'd they think was going to apply for this job? As far as supporting this activity- remember when the Catholic Church took over that school for deaf boys in Ireland? The priests were hammering those tykes night and day, figuring nobody could hear the screams, but word got out, and it went up the ladder. Guess who killed the investigation? Ratzo, the current pope. It comes from the top. By the way- none of this exists in any of the other religions, where it's okay to like women.
Bob Ratto October 05, 2012 at 09:00 PM
http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/326354--ten-worst-countries-for-women Read, learn...
Sara October 05, 2012 at 10:11 PM
Ralph, while many of those thoughts are true, one clearly stands ou: " It's a mistake to view the new Archbishop in political terms". I would agree if he stayed within the realm of the Church, God, Believers and the relationships therein. But he's not, is he? He and the Church are attempting to impose their beliefs on all US communities, Catholic or not, by initiating political actions such as Prop 8. Witness other recent statements from Bishops, such as the one in Illinois that claimed no one who believes LGBT people should have legal equality should receive Communion, or the one who said that voting for a Democrat will endanger a voter's eternal soul. Civil marriage and the Catholic Sacrament are not the same; yet the Church believes it has dominion over both. Religious organizations have no right in America to try to limit which consenting adults can enter into a civil marriage contract. Decades from now such attempts will seem as biased and bigoted as those that attempted to stop mixed race marriages.
Edward Mainland October 05, 2012 at 10:11 PM
If the Archbishop continues to drive while drunk, I just hope he stays out of Novato.
Sara October 05, 2012 at 10:20 PM
Jesus of Nazareth was by all accounts, a leftist, progressive, socialist liberal. His was a message of "Love Thy Neighbor" and His goal was to bring people into His Church by showing them Love and Compassion. Especially those shunned by others. As such, he would have welcomed LGBT people into his community with open arms. The current exclusion of gays and trans people from the Church, going so far as to create a whole new class of Sin and the attempts to reduce them to legal second class citizenhood in America can only be the work of false prophets in search of riches and power, as Jesus would never, ever promote such hatred and exclusion.
JVR October 05, 2012 at 10:54 PM
It seems the main question here is, "Are your moral standards universal or are they relative?" The Archbishop's are obviously universal, whereas people who have no fixed moral values are relative - they can just make them up as they go along. This moral relativism is unfortunately as large a problem with Catholics as with the general populace, as you can see from the previous comments. As well, it always amazes me why the great majority can't separate the teachings of the Catholic Church from the people in the Church. JVR
HistoryLover October 06, 2012 at 01:11 AM
Excellent point.
HistoryLover October 06, 2012 at 01:12 AM
So true!
Robert Kuchem October 06, 2012 at 06:30 PM
All Roman Catholic bishops are hand picked by the Pope. The Pope is strictly against same sex marriage. Ergo, why would anyone be surprised that the new SF bishop is against same sex marriage? What really upset me was the shabby un-Christian way they treated Episcopal Bishop Andrus who was invited to the installation; but, when he arrived, was escorted to the cathedral basement and left waiting there until it was clear that he was unwelcome.
Steve November 02, 2012 at 06:56 PM
People who have moral values that are not derived from religious belief can still have ethics and beliefs that are not relativist.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something